NSW WILDERNESS RED INDEX

Published by the Colong Foundation for Wilderness Ltd (September, 1999)
2/332 Pitt Street Sydney NSW 2000 ph: 02 9299 3741; fax: 02 9261 2144
email keith@colongwilderness.org.au web site colongwilderness.org.au

NAME: Indi
NOMINATED BY: Not nominated (September 1999)
LOCATION: 50 km west of Jindabyne and 25 km south west of Corryong.
SIZE: Approx. 17,200 ha (in NSW)
Approx. 22,000 ha (in VIC)
TENURE: Kosciuszko National Park 14,000 ha
Crown land (NSW) (approx) 2,400 ha
Freehold land (NSW) (approx) 800 ha
Alpine National Park (VIC) (approx) 13,000
Proposed Alpine N. Pk (VIC) (approx) 9,000

Wilderness Declared (NSW):

None

Wilderness Not Declared (NSW):

Kosciuszko National Park;

Size: 14,000 ha
Percentage of entire NSW assessment area: 81 %

Crown land;

Size: 2,400 ha
Percentage of entire NSW assessment area: 18 %

Freehold land;

Size: 800 ha
Percentage of entire NSW assessment area: <1 %

Wilderness Declared (VIC):

None

Wilderness Not Declared (NSW):

Alpine National Park;

Size: 13,000 ha
Percentage of entire VIC proposal: 59 %

State Forest (Proposed Alpine National Park);

Size: 9,000 ha
Percentage of entire VIC proposal: 41 %

DESCRIPTION:

The geology of most of the high country of Kosciuszko National Park comprises a complex of granites which have intruded sandstone and other sedimentary rocks. During the Silurian Period, marine basins formed in the Tumut and Murray areas which received sand and volcanic material from surrounding areas. Included in these deposits were small deposits of limestone in the vicinity of Indi Caves in the Upper Murray. The marine deposits of the Upper Murray were then extensively folded during the Devonian. Since then, granitic batholiths emplaced 300 million years ago which formed the Main Range, have been subjected to repeated cycles of uplift and erosion. However, the gradual uplift of the Kosciuszko "plateau", which rises gradually from the eastern tablelands and plunges sharply to the west, occurred during the Tertiary Period. This uplift occurred along a number of fault (or fracture) zones, which were gradually eroded by streams into deep valleys and gorges, cutting into the plateau edges.

The vegetation of the area displays considerable altitudinal and climatic variation from the highest point in the wilderness, Mt Youngal (1,515m) and the Murray River Valley at the north-western corner of Kosciuszko National Park (360m). Only patches of sub-alpine woodlands of Snow Gum (Eucalyptus pauciflora ssp. niphophila) with the most common dominating understorey a Oxylobium ellipticum / Podocarpus lawrencii alliance are present above 1,400m. Between 1,400m and 1,100m are found the montane forests of the Snowgum alliance, including E pauciflora, E. dalrympleana, E. rubida, E. viminalis and E. stellulata. In the Geehi valley a disjunct population of E. kybeanensis is found very distant from its typical coastal escarpment environment. In the wetter south and south east aspects, wet sclerophyll forests of E. delegatensis occur. Below 1,110m open low woodlands are common along the lower Snowy River, dominated by E. melliodora but on exposed sites the two peppermints E. dives and E. radiata prevail. Interspersed with the woodlands are very significant areas of Poa and Stipa spp. native grasslands which are poorly conserved in parks.

The wilderness is drained to the west by tributaries of the Murray River. The eastern part of the area drains to the Swampy Plain River which is upstream of the Khancoban Pondage, part of the Snowy Mountains Hydroelectric Scheme.

Faunal distribution in the wilderness is poorly understood. The upper Murray River carries populations of Golden Perch, Silver Perch, Macquarie Perch, Murray Cod and several species of gudgeon and galaxids.

LAND USE HISTORY:

Aboriginal Aboriginal occupation of the area was seasonal and associated with the Bogong feasts of the summer months. Winter refuges were in frost-free valleys: the Djilamatang in the Upper Murray; the Walgalu in the Tumut; Jaimathang in the Omeo; the Ngarigo in the Lower Snowy Gorge; and the Ngunawal in the Upper Murrumbidgee.

Mining:

1852 Geologist and clergyman W B Clarke comments on the likelihood of gold in the area after hearing reports of stockmen.
Grazing Grazing occurred in the Kiandra area as early as the 1830s. Cattle were also grazed along the Tumut River from 1858.
1889 New South Wales Government introduces the Snow Lease system to prevent alienation of land and maintain the area for the use of all graziers during drought periods. This system was never effectively implemented and a "collective monopoly" by pastoral companies and local individuals arose.
1943 Department of Lands begins major review of Snow Lease system, the summit of the Main Range being withdrawn completely, and stock limits set elsewhere.
1950's Lobby against grazing intensifies with scientists increasing their criticisms: 1952 W. R. Brown’s David Memorial Lecture; 1954 A. B. Costin’s Study; 1957 Australian Association for the Advancement of Science Report recommends elimination of grazing to protect catchments; 1958 Soil Conservation Service and Catchment Areas Protection Board attempt to veto renewal of leases.
Graziers construct a number of huts within the Wilderness Area throughout this period (1852-1974), notably Geehi and Old Geehi..

Hydro-electricity:

1941 Premier William McKell makes the development of water resources of the Snowy Mountains part of his election policy.
1944 Kosciusko State Park Act passed, by which 75% of water catchments for the proposed hydro-electric scheme are conserved within the Park. Conservation of water resources for irrigation and power is the major reason behind the preservation of the park and the demise of grazing.
1949 - 1974 Snowy Mountains Hydro-Electric Authority (SMHA) founded by Act of Federal Parliament in 1949 for the implementation of the scheme. Construction involves seven power stations, a pumping station, 17 large dams and 225 km of aqueducts and channels. Total storage capacity is 7,000 gigalitres. The centre of the scheme became Lake Eucumbene, 5 km west of the wilderness area, which collects the runoff from the headwaters of the Snowy, Eucumbene, Tumut and Murrumbidgee Rivers.

The Geehi River which flows into the Wilderness Area is dammed.

The stored waters are redirected from their natural catchments to flow through tunnels, whence they are discharged into the Murray and Murrumbidgee river systems for agricultural irrigation. This has altered the natural flow pattern of the Swampy Plain River, eliminating its summer peaks.

SMHA constructed unsightly huts and an airstrip within the Wilderness Assessment Study Area during this period.

1997 Under the provisions of the Snowy Hydro Corporatisation Act 1997, the Snowy Mountains Hydro-electric Authority will become the Snowy Hydro Corporation and be privatised once the environmental flows for the Snowy River are determined.

The proposed Corporation will be granted a 75 year lease by the NPWS for a rental of $0.5 million a year. Further long term leases will also be granted to Transgrid for its powerlines that dissect the park. A Snowy Management Plan will regulate the activities of the Corporation. These activities cause widespread and on-going environmental problems. These activities include: quarries; exotic plantings on prominent roadways; inappropriate roads; and many powerline easements; artificial stream flows; and stream diversions that are an impediment to wildlife.

HISTORY OF CONSERVATION MEASURES:

1935 Myles Dunphy first proposes the extensive Snowy-Indi Primitive Area, establishing the basis for an Alpine National Park.
1943 Grazing leases revoked from the Main Range and other areas.
1944 Kosciusko State Park Act passed. The Indi wilderness assessment study area is included within the boundaries. This area was excluded from Myles Dunphy's Snowy-Indi National Park Proposal of 1935 because of the existence of the snow leases.
1958 Grazing ended in Kosciuszko National Park at altitudes above 1,350 metres.
1969 Kosciusko State Park declared a National Park under the National Parks and Wildlife Act. Grazing ended within Kosciusko National Park.
1974 First Kosciuszko National Park Management Plan contains four wilderness zones.
1976 The Helman et al Report identifies five areas in Kosciuszko National Park of the twenty areas which satisfied its definition of wilderness in eastern NSW.
1980 NPWS issues four "Planning Statement Issues" papers. One, concerning alpine huts, advocates removal of 18 huts from Outstanding Natural Areas. After considerable lobbying by hut enthusiasts only four are now likely to be removed. This leaves a considerable number of huts within Kosciuszko wilderness areas.
1981 7 June: The Environment and Planning Minister, the Hon Eric Bedford, gazettes 15,764 ha of former travelling stock, camping and water reserves as part of Kosciusko National Park.
1982 Management Plan changes zoning of several wilderness areas in Kosciusko National Park to other management types. Over 70,000 ha of wilderness is ‘lost’.
1986 Wilderness Working Group, appointed by Minister for Planning and Environment, the Hon Bob Carr, release their report.
1988 September: Victorian National Parks Association publishes the Australian Alps World Heritage Nomination Proposal, which includes the Indi Wilderness.
1990 Victorian National Parks Association propose a Pinnibar Primitive Area of about 12,000 ha incorporating the rugged Murray Gates section of the Murray River and the south east half of the Mt Pinnibar massif, a very prominent peak at 1771m. The primitive area covers a section of the Alpine Walking Track. Murray Gates in one of Australia’s premier whitewater canoeing venues.
1994 May: The Australian Alps Liaison Committee publish an independent report by biogeographer Professor J.B. Kirkpatrick which concluded that there is a strong case that the Australian Alps would meet all four natural property criteria for World Heritage listing.
1995 March: The Carr Government’s conservation policy commits it to the Australian Alps World Heritage proposal. Given the Kirkpatrick report, the Commonwealth and State Governments have a responsibility to develop a nomination report under both the World Heritage Convention and Intergovernmental Agreement on the Environment.
1999 April: Dept. of Natural Resources and Environment release North East Victoria - Regional Forest Agreement (RFA) directions report under the Commonwealth Regional Assessment Process (CRA) recommends 174,000 ha of additions to the existing reserve system, including an addition of approx. 3,000 ha in the VNPA proposed Pinnibar Primitive Area, that would secure its entire protection.
A further 6,000 ha of the CRA proposed formal reserve additions would compliment the existing 4,000 ha of National Park that follows the Murray River opposite Kosciuszko National Park. These proposed park additions create opportunities to expand the Indi Wilderness west over the Murray to link with the proposed Pinnibar Primitive Area, making a contiguous wilderness of 39,200 ha.
1999 31 May: The National Parks and Wildlife Service Southern Zone releases its Wilderness Assessment study areas for the Southern/Tumut CRA. Through this process, the Indi wilderness assessment study area will be examined.

THREATS:

Electricity The Snowy Mountains Hydro-electric Scheme has resulted in numerous works in and around the Wilderness Area. These include: dams (Geehi and Khancoban); huts and campsites (numerous); and powerlines.

Dams and powerlines have reduced the extent of the Wilderness Area. The Alpine Way, that is currently being upgraded and bituminised at great expense has also limited the Wilderness Area. The Bicentennial National Horseriding Trail follows the Alpine Way.

The radio installations on Mt Youngal, owned by the Snowy Mountains Hydro Corporation and by bushfire authorities, results in a seven kilometre, finger like incursion into the wilderness.

Recommendations: The leases and licences issued for Transgid and the proposed Snowy Hydro Corporation should cover as small an area of the park as possible and be limited to existing structures. The Snowy Management Plan that regulates these facilities in the park should be subject to public comment and review. It should provide opportunities for removal of inappropriate infrastructure, such as the radio installation on Mt. Youngal. The Plan should guarantee access rights for park visitors, ensure the leased lands remain in public ownership, prevent further hydro power development in the park and guarantee that the lease agreements cannot be transferred to third parties so as to avoid environmental responsibilities. In addition to the $0.5 million rental fee, the proposed Corporation’s lease should cover all maintenance and NPWS management costs.

Trails A number of trails traverse the Wilderness Area. These are: Youngal Fire Trail (approx. 7 km); Indi Fire Trail (approx 16 km); and several unnamed fire trails (approx. 14 km). Total: approx. 37 km. In Victoria the Pinnibar Track and the Pinnibar to Tom Groggin Track should be closed to restore wilderness values in the Pinnibar Primitive Area.

The environmental impacts of trails on wilderness areas are well known. These include: soil compaction and erosion; rubbish dumping; pig dogging; weed introduction and dissemination by NPWS and other vehicles; assisting feral animal ingress; enabling arsonists to light wildfires in remote areas; and other adverse environmental impacts related to off-road vehicle use and horseriding.

Recommendations: Maintenance of management trails in wilderness areas violates the spirit of the Wilderness Act. The existing trails serve little purpose and should be rehabilitated. The wilderness area is currently surrounded by perimeter service trails and these should be adequate for management purposes. The best prescription to avoid fires in wilderness areas is to confine management trails to the edge, to prevent the spread of fire from outside. External management trails will also prevent fires spreading to adjoining areas. Where absolutely necessary, helicopter landing areas could be cleared for fire control. Fire trails should not be maintained and should be ripped by bulldozer and allowed to revegetate.

Freehold and
Crown Land
The Crown Land extension of approximately 2,400 ha to the north of the Wilderness Area, along the Indi Range, with small parcels of freehold land totalling 800 ha, brings grazing into the Wilderness. It may also serve as an access point for illegal grazing, and off-road vehicle use within the Kosciuszko National Park.

Recommendations: NPWS should negotiate acquisition of the area, which should be incorporated into the Indi Wilderness Assessment Study Area within the Kosciuszko National Park (E3 and E5 Management Units).

The NPWS and the Victorian Department of Natural Resources and Environment should enter into negotiations to acquire the Tom Groggin Station which has good access from the Alpine Way, with some form of camping facility on the disturbed land providing an accommodation node for the area.

Huts There are 4 structures in the Wilderness Area identified as huts. They range from constructions such as Old Geehi and Geehi, a day use hut, to ruins such as Doctors.

The NPWS is now considering allowing some huts to be rebuilt and expanded, not necessarily along heritage lines.

Huts lead to concentrated discharge of sewage into the environment, excessive litter, tree felling for firewood, fire scorches, and soil erosion.

Recommendations: The following huts have been identified by NPWS and/or are Snowy Mountain Authority huts and should be removed from the wilderness area immediately:

L73 Hoggs.

The following huts are contained within the area and should be managed as Historic Ruins and allowed to naturally disintegrate:

L95 Old Geehi;

L66 Geehi;

L60 Doctors.

CONTACT ORGANISATIONS AND INDIVIDUALS

Colong Foundation for Wilderness Ltd
Level 2, 332 Pitt Street
SYDNEY NSW 2000
Contact: Keith Muir (Director) Ph: (w) 02 9261 2400
FAX: 02 9261 2144
e-mail: keith@colongwilderness.org.au

The South East Forest Alliance
C/- National Parks Association
P O Box A96
Contact: Noel Plumb Ph: (wk) 02 9233 4660
FAX: 02 9233 4880
Mob: 0412 975 575
e-mail npansw@bigpond.com

Return to NSW Wilderness Index